Evolution of Due Process and Mitigation Safeguards in Death Penalty Jurisprudence

UPSC Relevance 

GS Paper II: Structure, Functioning of the Judiciary, Criminal Justice System, and Fundamental Rights. 

Why in News 

Recent Supreme Court rulings (Dupare v. Union of India, Waris v. State of MP) reinforce that sentencing compliance laid down in Manoj (2022) is rooted in Articles 14 and 21, making death sentences invalid without full mitigation procedures. 

Background 

• The Exceptionality Principle (Bachan Singh, 1980): Upheld the constitutionality of the death penalty under Section 354(3) CrPC (now Section 393(3) BNSS), establishing that life imprisonment is the rule and death is the exception reserved for the rarest of rare cases.

 • Jurisprudential Aberrations: The Machhi Singh (1983) and Ravji (1995) rulings shifted focus primarily to the crime gravity over the convict\'s circumstances, leading to executions later declared per incuriam in Santosh Kumar Bariyar (2009).

 • Key Facts:  o In 2025, the Supreme Court acquitted accused persons in 10 out of 19 capital cases due to flawed investigations. o Over 95% of trial court death sentences in 2025 failed to comply with Manoj sentencing guidelines. 

Impact & Measures

 • Major Implications & Challenges: 

o Procedural Non-Compliance: Trial courts frequently award death sentences on the same day as conviction without gathering mitigation reports.

 o High Rate of Acquittals: Over a third of capital cases decided by High Courts and the Supreme Court in the last decade ended in acquittals, exposing systemic investigative errors. 

o Irreversibility Risk: Flawed prosecutions paired with coerced confessions risk catastrophic judicial errors. 

• Judicial & Procedural Measures: o Mandatory Compliance (Manoj Guidelines): States must submit conduct reports, psychiatric evaluations, and probation officer studies before arguing for the death penalty.

 o Burden of Proof on State: The prosecution must prove with concrete evidence that the possibility of reformation is completely foreclosed. 

o Constitutional Rights Integration: Sub-standard sentencing hearings violate Articles 14 and 21 and remain open to judicial review even after finality (Dupare, 2025). 

Essential Definitions

 • Rarest of Rare Doctrine: Legal standard mandating that capital punishment be awarded only when options for life imprisonment are unquestionably foreclosed. 

• Mitigation Evidence: Information concerning an accused\'s background, mental health, and custodial conduct presented to justify a lesser sentence than death. 

Legal and Constitutional Framework 

• Article 21 & Article 14: Protect the right to life and personal liberty, guaranteeing fair, just, and reasonable procedures.

 • Section 393(3), Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023: Mandates recording special reasons when awarding capital punishment. 

• 262nd Law Commission Report (2015): Recommended the abolition of the death penalty for all crimes except terrorism-related offenses and waging war.

 Conclusion Strict adherence to individualised sentencing and procedural safeguards is a constitutional prerequisite for capital punishment. Protecting human dignity and enforcing due process ensures the justice system guards against irreversible judicial errors. 

DICS Branches

Our Branches

DICS Ahmedabad

Ahmedabad

(Head Office)

Address : 506, 3rd EYE THREE (III), Opp. Induben Khakhrawala, Girish Cold Drink Cross Road, CG Road, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad, 380009.


Mobile : 8469231587 / 9586028957

E-mail: dics.upsc@gmail.com

Gandhinagar

Address: A-306, The Landmark, Urjanagar-1, Opp. Spicy Street, Kudasan – Por Road, Kudasan, Gandhinagar – 382421


Mobile : 9723832444 / 9723932444

E-mail: dics.gnagar@gmail.com

DICS Vadodara

Vadodara

Address: Tithi Commercial Complex, 401/402 Productivity Road, Opp. Productivity House, Alkapuri, Vadodara, Gujarat – 390007


Mobile : 9725692037 / 9725692054

E-mail: dics.vadodara@gmail.com

DICS Surat

Surat

Address: 403, Raj Victoria, Opp. Pal Walkway, Near Galaxy Circle, Pal, Surat-394510


Mobile : 8401031583 / 8401031587

E-mail: dics.surat@gmail.com

DICS Ahmedabad

Ahmedabad (Associate Partner) Edukreme UPSC-GPSC Powered by DICS

Address: 303,305 K 158 Complex Above Magson, Sindhubhavan Road Ahmedabad-380059


Mobile : 9974751177 / 8469231587

E-mail: dicssbr@gmail.com

DICS New Delhi

New Delhi(In Association with Edge IAS)

Address: 57/17, 2nd Floor, Old Rajinder Nagar Market, Bada Bazaar Marg, Delhi-60


Mobile : 9104830862 / 9104830865

E-mail: dics.newdelhi@gmail.com